doodlebeats

Updated

WHAT THE RESEARCH SAYS

The beat between
two notes.

Play two notes that almost match.

You hear a slow wobble, louder and softer, at the difference between them. Musicians tune by it. Feed one tone to each ear through headphones and the brain hears a beat that is not in either signal: the binaural beat.

DIFFERENCE is the beat

Sort the claims
A person seen from behind wearing over-ear headphones, sitting by a bright window with a cup of tea on the sill
AI-generated image, not a photograph of a real person or place.
  • Two tones, one wobble
  • Headphones make it binaural
  • Evidence still mixed
  • Real sound, modest claims

THE SHORT ANSWER

The beat is real.
The claims vary.

Acoustic beats are basic physics.
What binaural beats do to the mind is still being tested.

PHYSICS

Tune by the wobble

When two notes are close, you hear a beat at the difference between their frequencies. As a string comes into tune, the beat slows and stops.

Sort the claims

THE ILLUSION

One tone in each ear

Play slightly different tones separately to each ear and you hear a third tone pulsing at the difference. It works in the range of about 1 to 30 Hz.

Hear it yourself

THE STUDIES

Results point both ways

A 2019 meta-analysis found a medium effect on memory, attention, anxiety and pain. A 2023 review found brainwave results inconsistent.

See the numbers

A QUICK CLAIM CHECK

How solid is
each claim?

Pick a claim about beats to see what the evidence says. The bar shows how strong the support is in the sources below.

Claim check

Choose a claim
Beats help tune instrumentsWell established

The beat frequency equals the difference between the two notes. Physicists describe beats as useful in practice for measuring frequencies and tuning instruments.

Binaural beats can be heardWell established

Two slightly different tones, one in each ear, produce the sensation of a third tone pulsing at the difference, in the range of about 1 to 30 Hz.

They help memory or anxietySome support

A 2019 meta-analysis of 22 studies found a medium overall effect on memory, attention, anxiety and pain perception. The effect depended on frequency and timing.

They sharpen sustained focusNot confirmed

A 2022 set of three experiments with 16 Hz beats found no consistent evidence that they improve sustained attention, its subjective feel or pupil-based arousal.

They retune your brainwavesInconsistent

A 2023 systematic review of 14 EEG studies found five supporting brainwave entrainment, eight contradicting it and one mixed.

Sources: Physclips (UNSW Sydney); Garcia-Argibay et al. 2019; Robison et al. 2022; Ingendoh, Posny and Heine 2023.

Based on a physics teaching page from UNSW Sydney and peer-reviewed studies in Psychological Research and PLOS ONE. This is general information, not medical advice.

TWO NUMBERS WORTH KNOWING

Promising in one review,
patchy in another.

One figure from a meta-analysis of effects,
one from a review of brainwave studies.

g = 0.45

Overall effect size across 22 studies

Pooling 35 effect sizes on memory, attention, anxiety and pain, the meta-analysis found a medium, significant effect. Exposure before a task did better than exposure only during it.

EFFECTS · PSYCHOLOGICAL RESEARCH 2019

5 of 14

EEG studies backing entrainment

Five studies fitted the idea that the brain falls into step with the beat, eight contradicted it and one was mixed. The authors note the studies used very different methods.

BRAINWAVES · PLOS ONE 2023

Robison and colleagues (2022) set out to test the attention finding with 16 Hz beats and, across three experiments, did not see a consistent benefit. More standardised studies are needed.

FOUR WAYS TO LISTEN

Hear the beat,
keep your ears safe.

You can hear acoustic beats with any two instruments. Binaural beats need headphones, because each ear must get its own tone.

  • Play two near-matching notes

    Sound two notes that are almost the same. The slow wobble you hear is the beat, at the difference between them.

  • Tune until it stops

    Adjust one string while the other rings. The beats get slower as the pitches come together, then fade out.

  • Use headphones for binaural beats

    Binaural beats need one tone to go to each ear separately, which is why studies and tracks use headphones rather than speakers.

  • Keep the volume comfortable

    The NHS says the volume should be just high enough for you to hear it comfortably, whatever you are listening to.

Two steel tuning forks of slightly different sizes lying side by side on a wooden table
AI-generated image, not a photograph of a real person or place.
Hands turning a tuning peg on the head of an acoustic guitar, with the strings catching the light
AI-generated image, not a photograph of a real person or place.

WHY THE RESULTS DIFFER

Different beats,
different tests.

Studies use different beat frequencies, different background sounds, different listening times and different tasks. The 2019 meta-analysis found that the frequency, the time spent listening and when the listening happened all changed the size of the effect.

The 2023 review found the 14 EEG studies so varied in how they made the beats and measured the brain that their results were hard to compare. Its authors call for standard methods before firm conclusions are drawn.

Questions

Questions people ask

What is a beat in sound?

When two tones with similar frequencies play together they drift in and out of step, so the sound grows louder and softer. The rate of that wobble, the beat frequency, equals the difference between the two frequencies.

What makes a binaural beat different?

The two tones are presented separately, one to each ear. The listener senses a third tone pulsing at the difference frequency, although it is not in either signal. It can be perceived from about 1 to 30 Hz.

Do binaural beats change brainwaves?

The evidence is inconsistent. A 2023 systematic review of 14 EEG studies found five results in line with brainwave entrainment, eight contradicting it and one mixed.

Do binaural beats help you concentrate?

Findings conflict. A 2019 meta-analysis reported a positive effect on attention, but a 2022 study of 16 Hz beats found no consistent evidence of better sustained attention.

How loud should I listen?

The NHS advises not listening to music too loudly: the volume should be just high enough for you to hear it comfortably.

References

  1. Physclips, UNSW Sydney: Interference beats and Tartini tones
  2. Garcia-Argibay, Santed and Reales (2019): Efficacy of binaural auditory beats in cognition, anxiety, and pain perception, a meta-analysis. Psychological Research
  3. Robison et al. (2022): The effect of binaural beat stimulation on sustained attention. Psychological Research
  4. Ingendoh, Posny and Heine (2023): Binaural beats to entrain the brain? A systematic review. PLOS ONE
  5. NHS: Hearing loss

ABOUT THIS NAME

doodlebeats.com could be yours.

doodlebeats.com is part of the DoodleSale portfolio. Check the current listing and available purchase or lease options.

Explore this domain